Web Site Evaluation - Criteria
Why evaluate web sites?
- Almost anyone can publish on the Web
- Many Web resources are not verified by editors and/or fact checkers
- Web standards to ensure accuracy are not fully developed
How to evaluate web sites
- Authority
- Is the page actually a journal article from a peer-reviewed journal or a book published by a major press?
- Which domain is the Website from (.gov and .edu are more reliable than .com)
- Who wrote the page (Is it signed? Does the author give biographical information or credentials?)
- Objectivity
- Does the author or publisher have a bias that could affect the reliability of the information?
- Any site that is trying to sell product has a bias
- Accuracy
- Does the source provide citations so you can verify the information?
- Are the citations to other websites or are they to journal articles and books?
- Currency
- When was the information written?
- When was it last updated?
General Tips
- Never quote from Wikipedia (use the articles to get the gist of the subject and mine the reference list.)
- For tips on searching for authoritative websites, [link]
Last modified: 10/6/2010 9:19 AM by M. Potter
